Today’s post is courtesy of the photographer, Sarah Rhodes, who shares her story about taking contemporary comparison shots to match the images from our Tyrrell photographic collection for our group on Flickr Tyrrell Today.
“Armed with several prints from the Tyrrell Collection, I set out to find out exactly how much Sydney’s business district has changed in 100 years. It was strange to find that many of the magnificent examples of architecture I was looking at in my bundle of photographs had been demolished during the 1960s. Forty years ago does not seem to be very long ago to be making, what I believe to be, devastating decisions. The State Premier Wing of the State Office Block replaced the Free Public Library in 1967, and then in 2004 Renzo Piano’s Aurora Place was built on the site. The Australian Club continues to operate from 165 Macquarie St but is no longer the stately building it was. The Australia Hotel on Castlereagh St, known as a wartime landmark and ‘the hotel of the Commonwealth’, was demolished in 1971 and replaced by a 35-storey office block built by its namesake MLC Insurance and Finance group. I tried to imagine why local governments would have agreed to knock down architecture now so highly valued.
After a little research I discovered it was not until the Bicentenary in 1988 that Australians became aware of their national heritage. Since then, restoration and renovation has become very fashionable. The trend has consumed homeowners and fuelled an entertainment industry, by making television shows like Channel 9’s Renovation Rescue.
My Tyrrell ‘Then and Now’ expedition started by visiting the Queen Victoria Building. As you can see in this picture it has seen few changes since it was completed in 1898. At the time it was built, the economy was in deep recession and so the government used the project of building a fresh produce market to employ a large number of workmen. The building was drastically remodeled in the 1930s and faced demolition in the 1950s. Thankfully, it was saved by a Malaysian company, which restored it to its former glory.
This experience has left me looking at every building and analysing its historical value. It has made me ask how we are assessing which buildings have heritage value and which are replaceable. I look around my suburb at gorgeous 1940s and 1950s bungalows being converted into modern townhouses and apartments where rendering and huge panels of glass dominate. Will we look back at those lost homes with regret or will we be happy to have adapted to our climate, creating light and airy suntraps?
I recommend anyone who is interested in architecture or our colonial history to take a walk through Sydney’s CBD with a few print outs that have been geo-tagged from the Powerhouse Museum’s Tyrrell Collection. You may even be pleasantly surprised to find many of the original buildings still standing proudly.”
References: Demolished Houses of New South Wales, an exhibition curated by James Broadbent and Joy Hughes, mounted at Elizabeth Bay House in 1988.
Photography by Sarah Rhodes
© All rights reserved.
Recent comments